Knockout questions: examples by role, and the rule for each

Updated

A knockout question has one disqualifying answer that you decide before anyone applies: "no" to "can you work nights" ends the application, whatever else the person says. A scored question has no wrong answer, only better and worse ones, and you compare candidates on it.

Below are pre-screening questions for eight kinds of jobs, each with the answer that knocks a candidate out and the reason it is a real requirement. Replace the [placeholders] with your own numbers. For full screening sets that also include scored questions, see 40 screening questions for 8 professions.

Knockout questions by role

Call center and customer support

Question Answer type Knocks out when Why it is a real requirement
This role answers customers in [language]. Can you hold a phone call in it? yes/no no Every call is in that language
Our lines are staffed [days], [start]–[end]. Can you work shifts anywhere in that range? yes/no no The rota covers the whole range; fixed hours can't be guaranteed
Can you attend paid training on [dates], [hours]? yes/no no Nobody takes calls before passing the product training
Can you type at least [40] words per minute? We test it at the interview. yes/no no Notes are logged during the call; saying it is tested keeps answers honest

Warehouse associate

Question Answer type Knocks out when Why it is a real requirement
The job involves lifting boxes up to [23] kg many times per shift. Can you do that, with or without reasonable accommodation? yes/no no Lifting is the work itself; the accommodation wording keeps it lawful
Can you work the [22:00–06:00] shift, [days]? yes/no no Only that shift is open
Can you stand and walk for a [10]-hour shift with breaks every [2] hours? yes/no no Picking is done on foot across the floor
Can you work in our cold store, which is kept at [2–4] °C? yes/no no Drop it if the site has no chilled area
Are you available for the whole season, [start date] to [end date]? yes/no no A peak-season contract with training up front

Delivery driver

Question Answer type Knocks out when Why it is a real requirement
Which driving licence do you hold? choice anything below [category/class] Driving the van without it is illegal
Have you held that licence for at least [2] years? yes/no no Often a condition of the company's vehicle insurance; check yours
Do you have [penalty points / a driving ban] on your licence right now? choice more than [6] points, or a ban The insurer sets the limit; copy theirs
Can you start at the depot at [06:30] on [days]? yes/no no Vans are loaded and leave on a fixed schedule
This route has [80–120] drops a day and carrying parcels up to [15] kg to the door. Can you do it, with or without reasonable accommodation? yes/no no Describes the actual workload instead of asking about fitness

Retail and cashier

Question Answer type Knocks out when Why it is a real requirement
Can you work at least [two] weekend days a month? yes/no no Weekends are the busiest days and are shared across the team
Can you work until closing at [22:00] and stay for the cash-up? yes/no no Every shift ends with counting the till
This store sells alcohol. Are you [18] or older? yes/no no Only where a law sets a minimum age for selling it; otherwise drop it
The job is [20] hours a week, [days]. Is that the number of hours you're looking for? yes/no no The contract hours are fixed

Sales rep

Question Answer type Knocks out when Why it is a real requirement
The pay is [base] plus commission, around [on-target earnings] at target. Does this structure work for you? yes/no no People who need a fixed income leave in the first months
The role covers [territory] and involves [3] days a week of client visits. Can you travel this much? yes/no no Field sales means visits; drop for inside sales
Do you hold a valid driving licence and have access to a car for client visits? yes/no no Only when the territory can't be covered by public transport
The job requires [licence or certificate, e.g. a state insurance licence]. Do you hold it, or will you have it by [date]? choice neither Selling the product without it is not allowed

Cleaner

Question Answer type Knocks out when Why it is a real requirement
The shifts are [05:30–08:30] on weekdays, before the [office] opens. Can you work them? yes/no no The site can only be cleaned when it's empty
Can you get to [site address] by [05:30], before public transport may be running? yes/no no Ask about arriving on time, not about owning a car
The job requires [a background check / site security clearance]. Are you willing to go through it? yes/no no Only for sites that require it: schools, hospitals, secure offices
You will work alone on site, with a phone check-in every [hour]. Is that OK for you? yes/no no There is no team on the night or early shift

Waiter or barista

Question Answer type Knocks out when Why it is a real requirement
Can you work [Friday and Saturday] evenings until [midnight]? yes/no no The two busiest services of the week
Do you have [a food hygiene certificate], or can you get one before your first shift? choice neither Only where the law or your licence requires it
We serve alcohol. Are you [18] or older? yes/no no Only where a law sets a minimum age for serving it
The [café] opens at [06:30]. Can you start at [06:00] for opening shifts? yes/no no Opening is part of the rota for everyone

Remote roles

Question Answer type Knocks out when Why it is a real requirement
Are you legally authorised to work in [country]? yes/no no You can only hire there; ask about sponsorship in a separate question
Will you need visa sponsorship now or in the future? yes/no yes Only if you truly can't sponsor
Our core hours are [14:00–18:00 UTC]. Can you be online then, every working day? yes/no no Meetings and handovers happen in that window
Do you have a computer with [specs or OS] and an internet connection of at least [25] Mbps? yes/no no Drop it if you send equipment
Do you have a quiet space where you can take calls without background noise? yes/no no Only for roles on calls with customers

Knockout or preference: how to tell

Ask: could a person with the "wrong" answer do this job after reasonable training or accommodation? If yes, it is a preference, and it belongs in the scored questions, not the knockouts.

  • Knockouts: a licence the law requires, a shift that is the only one open, legal right to work, a language every call is in.
  • Preferences: "experience with Zendesk" (learned in a week), "2 years in retail" (a good newcomer beats a weak veteran), "own car" when the real need is arriving by 06:00.

Use one or two knockouts per job, three at most. Every extra one removes people you could have trained, and you never see who they were.

Wording mistakes that make a knockout useless or unfair

  • Two questions in one. "Can you work nights and weekends?" A person who can do nights but not Sundays answers "no" and is gone. One requirement per question.
  • Leading questions. "You're comfortable with physical work, right?" Everyone says yes. State the real load and ask if they can do it: "boxes up to [23] kg, many times per shift".
  • A proxy instead of the requirement. "Do you own a car?" when you need someone at the site by [05:30]; "Do you have a degree?" when you need someone who can write a clear email. Ask about the requirement itself.
  • Vague words. "Flexible availability" means something different to everyone. Name the days and hours.
  • Free text for a knockout. "Tell us about your availability" can't be checked against a rule. Use yes/no or a fixed choice.

What must never be a knockout

Questions about protected characteristics: age, sex, pregnancy and family status, health and disability, nationality and ethnicity, religion. Rejecting on them is unlawful discrimination in many countries, and asking about them invites the claim that you did. Ask about the requirement instead:

Instead of Ask
Do you have children? / Are you married? Can you work the [22:00–06:00] shift on [days]?
How old are you? Are you [18] or older? (only where a law sets a minimum age for the task)
What is your nationality? / Are you a citizen? Are you legally authorised to work in [country]?
Do you have any health problems or disabilities? Can you [lift up to 23 kg / stand for 8 hours], with or without reasonable accommodation?
Is [language] your native language? Can you hold a phone call with customers in [language]?
Do you go to church / pray during the day? Can you work [Saturdays]? (and talk about adjustments if they ask)

The rules differ by country and sometimes by state or region, so check the local ones before you set an automatic rejection.

How to ask knockout questions: form, ATS or chat

  • Application form. Make knockouts required yes/no or dropdown fields at the top. A form can't clarify an answer like "mostly yes", so word the question so that only yes or no fits.
  • ATS. Most can auto-reject on a set answer. If you turn it on, send a neutral rejection that doesn't name the question, and test the form yourself before going live: a reversed rule rejects everyone who qualifies.
  • Chat. A chat can ask back when the answer is unclear ("I can do some weekends") instead of rejecting on it.

In Crutor a knockout question is called a deal-breaker. In the app's job editor you set a question's Effect on score to “Deal-breaker” and write the rule in When it's a deal-breaker (for example “can't work weekends”). The bot asks the question in the chat and clarifies unclear answers; if the answer matches the rule, the candidate's card in your team's group shows it under “Deal-breakers” with a low score. Nobody is rejected automatically and the candidate isn't told anything: someone on the team presses ⛔ Reject and chooses whether to send a rejection. How to create the job is in Your first job in 5 minutes.

Try it on your own job

Five minutes to describe it, and the link for candidates is ready.

Try it on your job